To Frame or Not to Frame? (Help with Fireplace Build)

Hi all, long time lurker, first time poster here (this is my first reddit post, EVER). I have plans to build a faux fireplace in my bedroom. I'm using a set of fake logs, that's also a heater, that I got at the ReStore, not an electric fireplace insert. I've seen conflicting directions on how I should go about this build. Some people go straight in with dimensional lumber like THIS. Others build a frame first and then cover it with some kind of substrate, like drywall or hardibacker, etc, like THIS EXAMPLE. My question is: Are there specific reasons why people build it one way or the other? Is it just personal preference? Are there pros and cons to think about for each? I've included a screenshot of the sketchup design for my fireplace (I'm VERY new to sketchup so don't look too hard

May 20, 2025 - 17:20
 0
To Frame or Not to Frame? (Help with Fireplace Build)
To Frame or Not to Frame? (Help with Fireplace Build)

Hi all, long time lurker, first time poster here (this is my first reddit post, EVER).
I have plans to build a faux fireplace in my bedroom. I'm using a set of fake logs, that's also a heater, that I got at the ReStore, not an electric fireplace insert.

I've seen conflicting directions on how I should go about this build. Some people go straight in with dimensional lumber like THIS. Others build a frame first and then cover it with some kind of substrate, like drywall or hardibacker, etc, like THIS EXAMPLE.

My question is: Are there specific reasons why people build it one way or the other?
Is it just personal preference? Are there pros and cons to think about for each?

I've included a screenshot of the sketchup design for my fireplace (I'm VERY new to sketchup so don't look too hard

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.